If your supplier reports a China customs export hold, first obtain the official notice or other verifiable customs evidence, the export declaration reference and the identity of the declared exporter. Establish the actual reason before agreeing to extra charges, changing payment or cancelling. If the issue concerns dual-use export controls, product specifications, end use and the applicable controls matter. Your contractual remedies require a separate review of the agreement, governing law and evidence.
This article concerns commercial goods awaiting export from China. It does not address goods entering China or clearance by the destination country’s customs authority.
Illustrative scenario: You paid an advance, production is complete, and the supplier says Chinese customs is checking export-control compliance. It requests more time and asks you to pay storage and testing costs. The immediate questions are what customs has actually required, which company must respond, and what your contract says about the resulting delay.
First, establish why the shipment has not been released
“Customs hold” is a description, not a diagnosis. Ask whether the problem involves an export-control question, an inaccurate or incomplete declaration, inspection, intellectual-property concerns, or a commercial dispute with a logistics provider. A freight forwarder refusing to move cargo over unpaid charges is different from an authority withholding release.
Request the Chinese wording of the notice or status message and the issuing office, date and reference. A translated email saying “customs is checking” does not establish which procedure applies. Compare the explanation with the shipment’s location and declaration history. If the supplier cannot provide a formal notice, ask what evidence exists and why no notice is available; different procedures produce different documents.
For dual-use questions, MOFCOM and General Administration of Customs Announcement No. 52 of 2026 provides for a specific questioning notice where no MOFCOM export licence has been presented and customs has evidence that the goods may fall within dual-use export controls. Questioning does not itself establish an offence or confiscation.
Documents to request from the supplier
Start a shared evidence file. Ask for copies that identify the shipment while protecting unrelated confidential information. The following is a buyer’s request list, not a statement that every customs delay generates every document.
| Document or information | What to check | What it cannot establish alone |
|---|---|---|
| Official notice or verifiable customs status | Issuer, reference, date, reason and response deadline | Whether the supplier has complied or will obtain release |
| Export declaration and reference number | Declared exporter, goods, quantity, port and dates | That the declaration is accurate or clearance complete |
| Contract, invoice, packing list and transport records | Whether the questioned goods are your order | Which party ultimately bears delay costs |
| Product specifications and technical material | Exact model, composition, performance and actual intended use | An authoritative export-control classification |
| Export-control assessment and any licence or consultation response | Product, destination, end user, scope and validity | Coverage of a different model, shipment or use |
| Submitted response and evidence of receipt | What was supplied, by whom, and when; missing-material requests | That either review clock has started without complete materials |
| Subsequent official feedback or result notice | Referral, testing, further evidence, classification or next procedure | That all other clearance requirements have been satisfied |
Ask for a dated chronology alongside the documents. Separate the date customs first questioned the goods from the date it received all materials. If there is a referral to MOFCOM, record when MOFCOM received the complete identification materials. Those dates can differ substantially.
Technical records must describe the goods actually presented. A generic catalogue, a report on another model or a supplier’s assurance that the item is “commercial only” may not answer the question raised.
Identify the exporter and the company responsible under your contract
Map five roles: your contract supplier, manufacturer, declared exporter, freight forwarder or declaration agent, and payment recipient. Record each company’s exact Chinese legal name and Unified Social Credit Code where applicable. Our Chinese company identity verification guide explains why an English trading name is insufficient.
If a trading company signed your agreement but another entity filed the export declaration, request the relevant agency or export arrangement and a written explanation of who controls the customs response. The exporter may possess documents that the salesperson does not. The factory may hold technical information, while the contracting supplier remains the party from which you must seek contractual performance.
Different companies do not automatically share contractual liability. Nor does the supplier necessarily escape its own obligations by blaming an export agent. Establish who promised what, who made the declaration, who received the money, and which documents connect them. Keep regulatory responsibilities distinct from the allocation of contractual risk.
How the dual-use questioning and identification process works
Announcement No. 52 was issued and took effect on 19 October 2026, replacing Customs Announcement No. 123 of 2025. Its questioning, document and non-release rules build on an existing framework; the whole procedure should not be described as newly introduced.
The consignor must respond within seven working days after receiving the questioning notice, with stamped materials and Chinese translations of foreign-language material. Required records include the declaration, contract, invoice, transport evidence, an explanation, technical information and other requested material. Relevant testing reports, if available, must accompany the technical evidence.
Customs assesses the response and may seek identification organised by MOFCOM. Goods concerned remain unreleased during questioning and identification. Goods found outside the dual-use category proceed with clearance formalities; that is not an unconditional release guarantee.
The timing needs particular care. Customs has 15 working days after receiving all consignor materials to complete its assessment or request MOFCOM identification. MOFCOM has a separate 15 working days after receiving complete identification materials to conclude. Time for submissions, supplementary materials and testing is excluded; major, difficult and other special cases are outside these limits. The official explanatory FAQ describes the ordinary two-stage timetable. It is not a promise of shipment within 15 or 30 working days.
The consignor may apply to split unrelated goods under the same declaration from the questioned goods. Separate clearance requires customs’ assessment and consent. This lawful option must not be confused with splitting shipments to evade controls.
Classification requires more than an HS code
The Dual-Use Items Export Control Regulations, particularly Article 14, require the exporter to understand performance and uses and allow consultation where classification remains uncertain. Controls may involve listed items, temporary controls and other legally specified circumstances. Not every export is dual-use, and a civilian sales description does not establish exemption.
MOFCOM’s official classification FAQ explains that customs commodity codes do not determine dual-use status. It also warns that a consultation response based on submitted documents is not a substitute for a required licence. Do not assume a licence obtained after declaration automatically cures an earlier compliance issue. Obtain advice on the lawful procedure for the actual shipment.
Review the contract before withholding payment or cancelling
An authentic customs problem and a supplier’s liability are separate questions. Review the signed agreement, purchase order, incorporated terms, correspondence and payment records together. The China manufacturing agreement guide and five China contract clauses to review provide broader preparation.
Focus on these issues:
- Export obligations: Who must classify the goods, obtain required permissions, provide end-use information and arrange export clearance? Check any incorporated Incoterms rule and named place alongside the rest of the agreement.
- Payment trigger: Is the balance due on production completion, inspection, specified shipping documents, dispatch or arrival? These are different events. An unresolved clearance issue does not by itself rewrite the agreed trigger.
- Delivery and notice: What constitutes delivery? Is time essential? What evidence and notice must the supplier provide, and by when?
- Additional costs: Who bears storage, testing, handling or demurrage, and under what conditions? Ask for invoices, causation and a contractual basis before accepting a charge.
- Force majeure, termination and refund: What conditions, notice requirements, cure periods and consequences apply? Separate relief from damages from termination and repayment rights.
Where PRC law governs, Civil Code Articles 180, 563, 565 and 590 provide relevant rules on force majeure, termination and notice. Article 590 ties relief to the effect of the event and requires timely notification and proof within a reasonable period; an event arising after delay does not excuse that earlier delay. A customs inquiry is not automatically force majeure. Examine its cause, timing, avoidability and actual effect on performance.
For international sales, first assess whether the CISG applies or has been excluded. Its rules on avoidance, suspension and exemption are distinct. In particular, an exemption under Article 79 does not automatically terminate the contract or create a refund right. Do not assume choosing Chinese law necessarily excludes the Convention.
If you need time to investigate, propose a written payment standstill or revised milestone. That is a negotiated measure unless an existing contractual or legal right already supports it. Unjustified non-payment or cancellation can create a further dispute.
Practical options while the shipment is on hold
Use the evidence to choose the next action rather than accepting an open-ended extension.
- Close the information gap. Have the responsible exporter identify missing documents, assign owners and supply evidence of submission. If you must provide genuine end-user or end-use information, make sure it is accurate and consistent.
- Track the actual procedure. Request dated updates, complete-material receipt evidence and any referral or testing request. A salesperson’s estimated sailing date is not an official deadline.
- Assess permitted partial clearance. Ask whether unrelated goods qualify for the announcement’s splitting procedure. Obtain approval before rearranging declarations or cargo.
- Agree a documented commercial plan. Consider a review date, delivery extension, cost cap, payment milestone or negotiated unwind. State whether rights are reserved and who bears which costs.
- Preserve recovery evidence. Keep original notices, messages, attachments, bank records and document versions. Record losses and reasonable mitigation steps without treating every expense as automatically recoverable.
Do not change technical descriptions, conceal parameters or misstate end use to obtain release. Changing the exporter or route does not remove applicable controls.
CLDD can assist with verifying transaction entities, reviewing Chinese-language transaction documents, and analysing contractual responsibility and available remedies within an agreed scope. Contract review is relevant to payment, delivery and termination questions; legal due diligence may be appropriate where the entity structure or wider transaction risk is unclear. Legal review cannot guarantee customs release, replace technical identification or ensure recovery of payment.
Contract changes to consider before the next order
Use the supplier due diligence checklist for background checks, then adapt the contract to the product and export arrangement. Review responsibility for classification and permissions; accuracy of technical and end-use information; identification of export agents; notice and document-sharing duties; payment and delivery milestones; storage and testing costs; and the consequences of prolonged or permanent non-performance.
Specify how the parties will cooperate without requiring either to breach controls. Consider a defined review point and a negotiated termination/refund mechanism. A clause should explain how it works with governing law, dispute resolution and the rest of the contract. A generic “customs delays are force majeure” sentence is unlikely to answer all these questions.
Short FAQs
Can I independently verify the supplier’s explanation?
Ask for the underlying Chinese notice, declaration reference and exporter authorisation for appropriate verification. A forwarded screenshot can omit context. There may be no public shipment-level search available to you; do not treat a failed public search as proof that the explanation is false.
What if the balance falls due during the review?
Check the contractual payment event and any applicable suspension right promptly. Requesting evidence or negotiating a standstill does not itself extend the due date. Obtain advice before simply withholding a sum already due.
Can I get my deposit back if export is impossible?
Possibly, but the answer depends on the agreement, governing law, responsibility for non-performance and the legal basis for ending the transaction. A supplier agreeing to refund is different from an established repayment right. Document the amount, deadline and responsible entity in any settlement.
Does a decision that goods are not dual-use settle everything?
No. It addresses that classification issue. Other declaration, inspection or clearance requirements may remain, and it does not decide the buyer–supplier dispute about delay, costs or payment.
What if the supplier refuses to share documents?
Ask which specific confidentiality restriction prevents disclosure and whether relevant copies or extracts can be provided securely. Record the refusal. Lack of evidence warrants closer review, but does not by itself prove dishonesty or establish a right to cancel.
Official sources and review date
Reviewed on 26 October 2026: MOFCOM/GACC Announcement No. 52 of 2026; MOFCOM’s questioning-and-identification FAQ and classification FAQ; the Dual-Use Items Export Control Regulations; the PRC Civil Code; and the CISG official text and status. Relevant original sources are linked near the discussion above.
This article provides general information and is not legal advice for a specific transaction. The appropriate response depends on the goods, official documents, contract, applicable law and current controls.
